The Tampa Affair as many call it was controversial but was a political plus for the Coalition. When John Howard said “We will decide who comes to this country and the circumstances in which they come” he outlined in a succinct phrase what is both a policy permissible for a serious government to undertake, and for a people to expect. Labor knew how unwise it would be to seriously challenge the PM’s reform in the area of the boat people. He worked out a policy whereby people seeking to escape their homeland for legitimate reasons aren’t forced to return, nor are they neglected at sea forbidden any assistance.
The “Pacific Solution” was agreed to by sufficient pacific nations that boat people could be redirected to locations in these countries and then work out their future plans there. It strengthened Australia’s grip on its sovereignty while seeking a humane approach. I believe that one of the Rudd Government’s most dreadful mistakes was to end this policy which statistics have shown was a huge success in terms of achieving its aims and substantially reducing the numbers arriving in this fashion without going through the proper procedures. It shows once again that even if Labor goes along with popular Coalition measures in opposition, once in government there is no certainty they will stick to it.
I do not understand how people could criticize this act of boldness. From my perspective as an American constantly hearing of comparatively much larger numbers of illegal arrivals through our borders and having governments of both parties for decades hiding as much as possible from this issue. I know for a fact that just as among regular Australians, average Americans by a large majority support a decisive leader keeping border entries in order, and actually know who is coming in. I would not want outsiders telling me how to run my country or tell how and how not to handle border/immigration concerns provided these problems are handled in an ethical fashion.